Notes on pattern testing
Exploring the many aspects of Test Knitting, Weekend Flash Sale, CraftDoodling Designs updates, etc.
I usually talk about test knitting experience during a pattern release, but I’ve always wanted to discuss the various aspects of test knitting in detail. Some of these points address frequently asked questions in the context of test knittting, while others cover issues that come up repeatedly.
I’m writing mostly from my own experience. Please keep in mind that different designers follow slightly different processes to get their patterns technically edited and test knitted. However, I believe most of these insights apply to test knitting in general.
The importance of test knitting
What exactly gets tested during test knitting? In short, test knitting ensures the clarity and flow of instructions and verifies that the item can be reproduced exactly as shown in the pictures—assuming the instructions are followed correctly.
A test knitter is the first person to actually work from the pattern instructions. How so?
The designer likely created their project from notes or a draft version of the pattern. A technical editor verifies the math and many other details in the written pattern but doesn’t necessarily knit the item using those instructions. This makes a test knitter’s experience the best approximation of what a future knitter will encounter.
Modifying a Pattern While Testing
The previous point might suggest that pattern instructions must always be followed exactly during test knitting. In practice, however, there are situations where modifications may be necessary or preferred. In such cases, it’s best to consult the designer to ensure your modifications align with the test’s goals and don’t interfere with the designer’s intent.
What is acceptable / not acceptable in garment testing
✨Slight adjustments to sleeve length, body length, or armhole depth are often unavoidable. Some knitters may prefer waist shaping when it’s not included in the pattern, or vice versa.
✨Matching both stitch and row gauge is ideal for garment testing. However, row gauge can be tricky, and adjustments are sometimes necessary. Usually they are not very difficult.
✨Many testers have their preferred finishing techniques, which may differ from what the designer has specified. It’s always okay to ask whether you can swap in your preferred method.
✨However, it’s best to stay true to the overall fit, style, and garment construction. For instance,
If the designer recommends 4–10 inches of bust ease, try to stay within that range.
Changing a pullover into a cardigan? That’s a big no!
When designers set these guidelines, they aim to maintain consistent fit and appearance across sizes. This is part of what you signed up to test!
I’m not against creative modifications—I love them! In fact I wrote a post about this topic in the past. But it’s a good idea to save those for after the test knit. You can always make another version to explore your ideas! 💙
Some points that come up in testing accessories
✨For simpler accessories where gauge is less critical, designers often include notes on lengthening or shortening. In these cases, focus on matching the schematic measurements for your chosen size—assuming you have enough yarn.
You may not be following the exact pattern numbers, but you’re testing the design’s adaptability, its compatibility with different yarns, and whether the finished measurements work as intended.
If you find my posts helpful, please share it with a friend who might like it too! 💙
Charts or Written Instructions?
I usually ask my testers whether they prefer working from charts or written instructions. This helps ensure both options are tested, though not every tester needs to use both.
Of course, I’m especially grateful for those "gold-standard" testers who knit some repeats from the chart and some from the written instructions. The same applies to video vs. written instructions for a technique—following just one is fine, but if you can compare both and offer feedback, that’s even better!
All this to say: don’t let a chart keep you from signing up for test knits.
Communication Is Key
Provide feedback as you knit. Stay engaged in the designated testing channel—whether it’s Slack, Discord, Ravelry, Instagram group chat, email, or another platform.
Timely feedback is especially valuable. Even if you’re delayed in finishing the item, try to share your notes well before the release date.
As a designer, I prefer to have as much feedback as possible before hitting the Publish button. It might still not turn out to be a perfectly written pattern, but I like to think that, as a designer-and-tester team, we’ve given it our best shot.
Testing Deadlines
Life happens! Sometimes you may need more time or even have to abandon a project. If that’s the case, let the designer know.
Many test knitters feel they aren’t contributing enough if they can’t meet the deadline. But remember: a pattern release is just the beginning of the pattern’s journey. If you finish later and add a project to Ravelry, you’re still adding tremendous value.
For First-Time Testers
Ideally, a test group should include both knitters familiar with the designer’s patterns and those who are not.
New testers bring fresh eyes to a pattern, which is invaluable. Those familiar with a designer’s writing style may unintentionally overlook unclear sections.
Experienced test knitters who are new to a particular designer can also offer valuable feedback, as their exposure to various pattern-writing styles helps them identify potential areas for improvement.
Keep Notes
My favorite way to (gently!) nudge my test knitters is by asking them to take notes as they knit. Whatever modifications you make and why you decided to do them are like gems for future knitters.✨
We, as knitters, thrive by learning from one another! Do you agree? Your notes could make a real difference for someone else. If you can, please take a moment to share them on Ravelry.
Do you enjoy testing patterns regularly? Please share your thoughts in comments. 💙
To let me know you liked what you read, you can also press the little heart icon at the bottom of the newsletter. ♥️ However, if you are clicking it from your inbox, you might have to wait until Substack opens in a browser and make sure the heart icon is indeed red. Thanks! 🥰
CRAFTDOODLING DESIGNS UPDATES
I don’t know if it’s the changing weather, but I’ve been in the mood for knitting accessories lately. I’ve started a shawl design and am already thinking of more.
What are you in the mood for knitting these days? 💗
Well, if you’ve been eyeing anything from my designs, I suppose I could offer a little something. 😊
Meera Shawl - One skein fingering weight pattern.
💥 FLASH SALE 💥
Enjoy 40% off my patterns on the total price when you buy at least 3 patterns from me this weekend.
Coupon Code : KNITMOOD
Valid until March 3, 2025, midnight PT.
I am honored to be teaching “Introduction to 2-color brioche” class at the Virtual Next Level Knitting Conference organized by TKGA, from April 4 - 6 2025. Please book your tickets, if interested.
Memories from my Brioche class last week at my LYS. 💙
Lori finished Ceremonial Grade Cowl and is all set for Bay Area Yarn Crawl in March. 💙 How about you? 😊 Please share in comments if you are making one or more of the three crawl cowls.
OTHER THINGS YOU MIGHT LIKE
READING UPDATES
Finished Reading 📖
Death at the sign of the Rook - Kate Atkinson
Currently Reading 📖
The Murder of Mr.Wickham - Claudia Gray
Until next time,
Kavitha. ♡
Currently, this newsletter is free to subscribe. If you like my work, please consider these other ways to support:
Click the ❤️ at the bottom of this post. If you are reading from your email inbox, this will open substack in web browser. Please allow it to open and make sure you see the red heart.
Share your thoughts in comments. I am here for the conversations. I hope you are too!
Introduce this newsletter to a friend!
Buy my patterns. I hope you find something you like.
I accept any of these with immense gratitude. Thank you!
Your new shawl pattern looks lovely. Enjoy this newsletter.
Regular and timely communication between the designer and testers is vital. Its a team sport. As a tester, when applicable, I test both charts and written instructions. I found the process rewarding and look forward to selecting my next test